On June 5, 2018, Russian President Vladimir Putin paid a one-day visit to Austria. Ahead of the visit, he gave an interview to news presenter Armin Wolf of ORF, Austria's largest media provider. In the interview, Putin stressed Russia's position on Europe, stating that Moscow does not want to weaken the European Union: "It is not our aim to divide anything or anybody in Europe. On the contrary, we want to see a united and prosperous European Union, because the European Union is our biggest trade and economic partner. The more problems there are within the European Union, the greater the risks and uncertainties for us."
Explaining that 40% of Russia's gold and currency reserves are in euro, he added: "Why should we shake up all of this, including the single European currency as a derivative of the rocking of the Union? I would like people in Austria and in the other European Union countries to put this idea out of their minds."
Below are excerpts of the interview:[1]
Putin with ORF news presenter Wolf. (Source: Kremlin.ru)
Russia-Austria Relations – Putin: 'Austria Is Our Traditional And Reliable Partner In Europe'
ORF news presenter Armin Wolf: "Mr. President, your first foreign visit takes you to Austria. Is this is a kind of incentive for a benevolent policy towards Russia on the part of the Austrian Government, which comes out against new EU sanctions and has not expelled any Russian diplomats over the 'Skripal case'?"
President of Russia Vladimir Putin: "I do not think such a highly respected European state as Austria needs any incentives. We have long enjoyed good and profound relations with Austria. Austria is our traditional and reliable partner in Europe. In spite of all the complications over the years, our dialogue in the sphere of politics, security and the economy has never been interrupted. Our trade with Austria grew by 40.5 percent last year. We respect Austria's position and its neutral status. Russia, of course, is one of the guarantors of this status, having taken part in the drafting of the state treaty.
"We cooperate with the Austrian Republic in various spheres: in the economy, as I have said, in politics and security. In the economy, we cooperate in various areas. Not only energy, though I would like to say more about it later on, but also in aircraft construction, aviation safety and hydroelectric engineering. More and more Austrian capital is invested in Russia. We see this as a sign of trust in the economic policy pursued by the Government of the Russian Federation.
"We are implementing major projects. Owing to our cooperation, Baumgarten, and therefore Austria, has become Europe's biggest gas hub.
"We have many common and similar interests, so we were glad to welcome Federal Chancellor Kurtz in Russia in February of this year. It is out of these considerations that my visit to Austria is being prepared and I hope will take place soon."
United Russia Relations With Austrian Parties – Putin: United Russia Would Be Happy To Develop Contacts With Other Political Forces As Well, Not Just With The Free Party Of Austria
Armin Wolf: "The Russian Government partially maintains good relations with some members of the Austrian Government. In 2016, the United Russia party signed a partnership agreement with the Freedom Party of Austria.[2] Why this party in particular?"
Vladimir Putin: "You said that the Russian Government maintains good relations with Austria and followed up this analysis from a purely party perspective.
"I was a co-founder of the United Russia party, but I am not currently a member because I am the head of the Russian state. It is true that the Russian Government is working in a very hands-on and fairly profound manner with their colleagues in Austria without displaying any political preferences.
"As regards the policy towards Austria, we have a national consensus to some extent, there are no political forces that oppose the development of relations with Austria, but there may be some preferences at the political level, at the party level. The fact that United Russia has established relations with the party you have mentioned – these are purely inter-party relations. I am sure that United Russia would be happy to develop contacts with other political forces as well."
Russia's Policy Towards Europe – Putin: 'It Is Not Our Aim To Divide Anything Or Anybody In Europe. On The Contrary, We Want To See A United And Prosperous European Union'
Armin Wolf: "You headed this party for a long time, now Mr. Medvedev is its leader. Many observers believe that the Russian leadership would like, through United Russia, to maintain links with nationalist parties because they want to divide the European Union. How do you account for the close links between the Russian leadership and the parties that are critical of the European Union?"
Vladimir Putin: "It would be better if you put this question to the Russian Prime Minister Mr. Medvedev, who is the leader of the party. But this is what I can say with a fair degree of certainty. It is not our aim to divide anything or anybody in Europe. On the contrary, we want to see a united and prosperous European Union, because the European Union is our biggest trade and economic partner. The more problems there are within the European Union, the greater the risks and uncertainties for us.
"The mere fact that our trade with European Union countries has dropped by half, from over 400 billion to 250 billion, speaks for itself. Why do we need to see a further drop? Why rock the European Union in order to suffer further losses and incur costs or miss possible benefits from cooperation with the European Union?
"On the contrary, we need to increase cooperation with the European Union. If we work at all or work more intensively with some than with others, we proceed from purely pragmatic considerations. We seek to cooperate with those who publicly declare that they are ready and willing to cooperate with us. This alone is the reason why our political parties, groups and movements have contacts at the political and party level with certain European ones, and not the wish to 'rock' or impede something within the European Union.
"We keep 40 percent of our gold and currency reserves in the euro. Why should we shake up all of this, including the single European currency as a derivative of the rocking of the Union? I would like people in Austria and in the other European Union countries to put this idea out of their minds."
Russian Trolls – Putin: 'Could It Be That The Media And Political Standards In The Countries Of The Consolidated West Have Been Driven Down To Such A Low Level That A Russian Restaurant Keeper Can Sway Voters In A European Country Or The United States?'
Armin Wolf: "This notwithstanding, the governments of Western countries, Europe and, first of all, the United States, are accusing Russia of using hackers to meddle in other countries' domestic politics. In all of your interviews you say that this is not so; however, there is no doubt that the so-called Internet Research Agency based in St Petersburg has been seeking for many years to influence public debate on Facebook. These so-called troll factories are owned by Yevgeny Prigozhin – you know him very well, he is referred to as 'Putin's chef', since he caters for all your guests. Is it good that a person who maintains such close relations with the Russian leadership is managing troll factories?"
Vladimir Putin: "You said 'Russia' and then switched to hackers, didn't you? By saying 'Russia', did you mean Russia as a state, or some Russian citizens, hackers, or some legal entities for that matter?"
Armin Wolf: "I was speaking about Mr. Prigozhin."
Vladimir Putin: "I will tell you about Mr. Prigozhin.
"Please make a distinction between the Russian Government, Russia as a state, Russian citizens and certain legal entities.
"You have just said that Mr. Prigozhin is referred to as 'Putin's chef.' Indeed, he runs a restaurant business, it is his job; he is a restaurant keeper in St Petersburg. But now let me ask you: do you really think that a person who is in the restaurant business, even if this person has some hacking opportunities and owns a private firm engaged in this activity – I do not even know what he does – could use it to sway elections in the United States or a European country? Could it be that the media and political standards in the countries of the consolidated West have been driven down to such a low level that a Russian restaurant keeper can sway voters in a European country or the United States? Isn't it ridiculous?"
Armin Wolf: "Mr. President, it may be good or bad but it is not the truth. Mr. Prigozhin does not only run restaurants, he has many businesses that have contracts with the Defense Ministry and receive a lot of government orders; he spends millions of dollars on the troll factory and people there write these posts. Why does a restaurant keeper need this?"
Vladimir Putin: "You can ask him. Russia as a state has nothing to do with this."
Armin Wolf: "But you know the man very well."
Vladimir Putin: "So what? I know many people in St Petersburg and Moscow. Ask them.
"There is such a personality in the United States – Mr. Soros, who interferes in all affairs around the world. I often hear from my American friends that 'America as a state has nothing to do with [his activities]'. There are rumors circulating now that Mr. Soros is planning to make the euro highly volatile. Experts are already discussing this. Ask the State Department why he is doing this. The State Department will say that it has nothing to do with them – rather it is Mr. Soros' private affair. With us, it is Mr. Prigozhin's private affair. This is my answer. Are you satisfied with it?"
Russia- U.S. Relations – Putin: 'Donald [Trump] Said He Was Worried About The Possibility Of A New Arms Race. I Fully Agree With Him'
Armin Wolf: "Mr. Prigozhin, along with 12 other Russian citizens, has been indicted in the United States for meddling in the presidential elections. You and Donald Trump talk so nicely over the telephone, but Trump has been President for a year and a half and there still has not been a bilateral summit between you, in contrast to Bush and Obama with whom you met within the first six months of their presidencies. Why is it taking so long?"
Vladimir Putin: "You should ask our colleagues in the United States. In my opinion, this is the result of the ongoing acute political struggle in the United States. Indeed, Donald Trump and I have, firstly, met more than once at various international venues and secondly, we regularly talk over the phone. Our foreign affairs departments and special services are working fairly well together in areas of mutual interest, above all in the fight against international terrorism. This work is ongoing.
"As for personal meetings, I think that the possibility of these meetings depends to a large extent on the internal political situation in the United States. The congressional election campaign is getting under way and then there will be the next presidential election, and the President of the United States is coming under attack over various matters. I think this is the main reason.
"In a recent telephone conversation, Donald said he was worried about the possibility of a new arms race. I fully agree with him. However, to prevent a possible arms race (we did not initiate such a course of events, we did not withdraw from the Anti-Missile Defense Treaty, we merely responded to the threats that arise for us from this, but I agree with the U.S. President) we should think about it, we should do something about it, give corresponding instructions to our Foreign Ministry and the US State Department. The experts should start working in a concrete way. I hope that someday this work in the interests of the United States and Russia, indeed in the interests of the whole world will begin, including between us personally."
The Korean Peninsula Crisis – Putin: 'We Will Do All We Can To Ease Tensions On The Korean Peninsula'
Armin Wolf: "Many are worried about the situation in North Korea. Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov recently visited there. Do you think a nuclear showdown between the United States and North Korea is a possibility?"
Vladimir Putin: "I do not even want to think about it. It is a dreadful idea. Russia, of all countries, is not interested in it because North Korea is our neighbor. Incidentally, one of the nuclear test sites, the one that I think North Korea is shutting down, is located, if my memory does not fail me, within 190 kilometers of the Russian border. This is something absolutely real for us.
"Therefore, we will do all we can to ease tensions on the Korean Peninsula. So of course we pin great hopes on the personal meeting between President Trump and North Korean leader Kim Jong-un, because mutual claims have gone way too far.
"I think this road – the road towards denuclearisation of North Korea – should be a two-way road. If the North Korean leader is backing up his intentions with practical actions, for example, giving up new tests of ballistic missiles, new nuclear tests, the other side should reciprocate in a tangible manner. In this connection, I consider it counterproductive to continue military activities, military exercises and everything that is related to this. I very much hope that the situation will move forward in a positive way.
"We for our part are ready to bend every effort towards this end. We have always been in contact with the North Korean leadership; we offer several joint tripartite economic projects. These are infrastructure projects, a railway from Russia to North Korea and further to South Korea, the pipeline project, work in the energy sector in a three-way or perhaps in a four-way format together with China.
"Incidentally, China has done a great deal to direct the situation towards détente and denuclearisation. If we pool our efforts, including in the framework of the Russia-China road map, our joint proposal to resolve the North Korean nuclear problem, I think we will achieve the desired results."
Flight MH17 – Putin: The Ukrainian Army, The Ukrainian Volunteer Battalions… All Use Soviet And Russian-Made Weapons
Armin Wolf: "One of the most complicated issues with regard to Russia is Ukraine. In 2014, Flight MH17 was shot down in Ukraine, 290 people died. The international investigative commission announced a few days ago that the jet was shot down by a Russian army missile system, that it was a convoy from Russia that had come to the Ukrainian insurgents in eastern Ukraine. There is a video; there are telephone conversations and dozens of eyewitnesses. You have been saying that this is not true for about a year but practically nobody believes your words.
"Are you not thereby putting the veracity of Russian statements at stake? Maybe it is time to acknowledge that the insurgents in eastern Ukraine used Russian military equipment to commit that horrendous crime?"
Vladimir Putin: "I want to note that both sides to the conflict – the Ukrainian army and even Ukrainian volunteer battalions who are accountable to nobody save their commanders, and the Donbass militia, the armed units in Donbass – they all use Soviet and Russian-made weapons. All of them. The two sides have all sorts of systems – both firearms, aviation, and anti-aircraft systems. All of them were made in Russia."
Armin Wolf: "But now they know what missile it was: a Buk system missile. It was a Russian army brigade in Kursk. This is known for a fact, yet you still deny it. Would it not be better to admit that the missile had indeed come from Russia? Would it not be better to officially acknowledge that Russia supported the insurgents in the east of Ukraine with weapons?"
Vladimir Putin: "If you collect all your patience and let me finish, you will find out my view on this issue.
"As I said, both sides use Russian-made weapons, and the Russian army has exactly the same systems the experts are talking about, which were certainly manufactured in the former Soviet Union or in Russia. This is number one.
"Number two. Russian experts have been denied access to the investigation, our arguments are not taken into consideration, and nobody in the commission is interested in hearing us out. Conversely, the Ukrainian side, which is a party interested in the results of the investigation, has access to it. Meanwhile, it is responsible at least for failing to prohibit civilian aircraft to fly in the conflict zone in violation of ICAO's international norms.
"We are still unable to get answers to some questions regarding the activities of Ukrainian air forces in that region, at that place and at that time. The tragedy we are talking about is terrible, and I feel immensely sorry for the victims and their families, but this investigation must be objective and comprehensive.
"Just a second, please, do not rush. Let me speak, otherwise we are going to have a monologue on your part instead of an interview."
Armin Wolf: "Nevertheless, let me say briefly – yes, we know where the missile came from. But what do Holland, Australia or Malaysia have to gain by blaming Russia if it was not a Russian missile that belonged to the Russian army?"
Vladimir Putin: "We do not see it that way; we have a different point of view. You now listed countries that allegedly believe that it was a Russian missile and that Russia is implicated in that terrible tragedy. I regret to disappoint you. Quite recently, Malaysian officials declared that they do not see Russia's complicity in that tragic event; they have no proof that Russia is implicated. Are you really not aware of that? Did you not see the statements by Malaysian officials?
"What do we think about this issue? If we really want to get to the bottom of things in that horrendous event and reveal all the factors that would allow us to render a final conclusion, all arguments should be taken into account, including the ones offered by Russia. And it would be entirely fair for Russian experts to have access to the investigation."
Armin Wolf: "The international investigative commission now claims that they have in fact taken into account all arguments. Many people do not believe Russian arguments because a few years ago in Crimea you said that the famous 'green men,' the fighters in green uniforms without identifying insignia, were all local self-defense forces. But a little later it was revealed that they were indeed Russian soldiers. After that, you admitted many times that those were Russian army personnel even though you denied that earlier. Why should we believe you now?"
Vladimir Putin: "Now that you mentioned Crimea. Do you know that in the mid 2000s, right in the vicinity of Crimea, a Russian civilian jet was downed over the Black Sea? It was done by the Ukrainian army during a drill. And the first reaction of the Ukrainian officials was that Ukraine had nothing to do with it. A civilian plane was shot down en route from Israel to Russia. Everyone onboard died, of course. Ukraine flatly denied its involvement in that terrible incident but had to admit it later. And why should we believe Ukrainian officials? So in response to your question about Crimea, I put the ball back in your court."
Armin Wolf: "I am not talking about Ukrainian officials, I am talking about you. You said many times in 2014 that you used the Armed Forces in Crimea to block Ukraine's interference. Later you admitted though that the Russian army was in Crimea, something you had denied before."
Vladimir Putin: "Russian forces have always been stationed there. Look, I would like you to try to understand what was actually happening there, not just repeat these things mechanically. Russian forces have always been present in Crimea. Our military contingent was there.
"One second, please, let me finish. Do you want to fire questions non-stop or hear my answers?
"The first thing we did when the events in Ukraine began… What kind of events? Let me tell you now, and you will say yes or no. It was an unconstitutional armed coup and seizure of power. Yes or no? Will you tell me?"
Armin Wolf: "I am not an expert on the Ukrainian Constitution."
Vladimir Putin: "You do not have to be an expert on Ukraine; you just need to be an expert on law, on the constitutional law of any country.
Referendum In Crimea – Putin: 'The Decision To Hold This Referendum Was Made By The Crimean Parliament, Which Was Elected In Strict Accordance With The Constitution And The Laws Of Ukraine Before Any Such Events…'
Armin Wolf: "I would not like to talk about Ukrainian politics, but about Russian politics. Allow me to phrase it differently. What should happen in order for Russia to return Crimea to Ukraine?"
Vladimir Putin: "There are no such conditions and there can never be.
"I will tell you why. You interrupted me again, but if you actually let me finish, you would understand what I mean. I will still do it.
"When the unconstitutional armed coup took place in Ukraine, and power changed hands by force, our army was legally deployed in Crimea – under the agreement on our military base there. The first thing we did was increase our contingent to guard our Armed Forces, our military facilities, because we immediately saw that they were being threatened. That is where it all began. I told you with confidence that there was no one else there, but our Armed Forces were there legally under an agreement.
"Let me finish, for God's sake. (Speaks German.) Seien Sie so nett, lassen Sie mich etwas sagen. [Please be so kind as to let me say something.]"
Armin Wolf: "I hate to interrupt you, but it is not about the Russian Black Sea Fleet. It was certainly based there. It is about those uniformed fighters without insignia. You said they were Crimeans, but they were not Crimeans; they were Russian servicemen."
Vladimir Putin: "I will get to this, please be patient. We have enough time.
"Our servicemen had always been stationed there. I said: our servicemen were there, but they did not get involved. But, when unconstitutional actions in Ukraine began to unfold, when people in Crimea felt danger, when trains started bringing aggressive nationalists there, when buses and personal vehicles were blocked, people naturally wanted to protect themselves. And the first thing that occurred was to restore the rights that Ukraine itself had issued by granting Crimea autonomy. This is where it all began – with a procedure in the parliament to establish its independence from Ukraine.
"Now, is this strictly prohibited by the United Nations Charter? No, it is not. The right of nations to self-determination is clearly stated there. And what did our Armed Forces do, even without expanding the contingent stipulated by the military base agreement? They ensured the independent free elections – an expression of the will of the people living in Crimea. By the way, the decision to hold this referendum was made by the Crimean parliament, which was elected in strict accordance with the Constitution and the laws of Ukraine before any such events. Therefore, nothing illegal …
"Just a second."
Armin Wolf: "As far as I know, the parliament had no right to make this decision. But let us continue our conversation. The annexation of Crimea was the first time a country in Europe annexed part of another country against its will. This was really seen as a threat to neighboring states, from Poland to the Baltic states, because it was assumed that minorities in these countries could also receive protection from Russian forces."
Vladimir Putin: "You know, if you do not like my answers, then do not ask me questions. But if you want to hear my opinion on the issues that I raise, then you need to have patience. I need to finish.
"So, Crimea gained independence through the free will of the Crimeans expressed in an open referendum, not as a result of an invasion by Russian forces.
"You are talking about annexation, but can we call a referendum held among all people living in the region annexation? Then Kosovo's self-determination was also annexation. Why do you not say Kosovo was annexed after the invasion of NATO troops? You do not say that. You are talking about the Kosovars' right to self-determination.
"The Kosovars did this by a parliamentary decision alone, while the Crimeans did it in a referendum, with an over 90 percent voter turnout – people living in Crimea came to vote for independence, and then for uniting with Russia, with about the same turnout – about 90 percent. Is this not democracy? What is it then? And what is democracy?"
Armin Wolf: "Mr. President, the referendum was still unconstitutional."
Vladimir Putin: "Why?"
Armin Wolf: "It did not comply with the Ukrainian legislation, the Ukrainian Constitution. It was not a free referendum, Western observers say.
"As for what you are saying about Kosovo, you have called Kosovo's declaration of independence immoral and illegal, and have not recognized it yet. How can this be?"
Vladimir Putin: "This is quite possible, and I will tell you why. Because during the political changes and military conflict in the former Yugoslavia, the UN Court issued a decision with regard to Kosovo (I can give you a quote), which explicitly said (read it and then read it out loud for your viewers and listeners): 'The consent of the central authorities of the country is not mandatory in determining the issues of sovereignty.' This is how the UN Court commented on the Kosovo events, and now you are saying…"
Armin Wolf: "There were some very clear conditions there that were not met in Crimea. This is what all international observers say."
Vladimir Putin: "What are they?"
Armin Wolf: "There is no one who would recognize that vote, there is no one who would recognize the annexation."
Vladimir Putin: "Your arguments sound completely unconvincing, because no one has to recognize the will of citizens residing in a certain area. This fully complies with the UN Court decision. There is no other interpretation, but some people are trying to find ways to interpret this situation differently."
Armin Wolf: "May I take you at your word?"
Vladimir Putin: "Try it."
Armin Wolf: "If so, then apparently people in Chechnya, Daghestan and Ingushetia could also organize a referendum and secede from Russia? Or organize an Islamic caliphate in your territory?"
Vladimir Putin: "Indeed, Al-Qaeda extremists wanted to tear off this territory from the Russian Federation and form a caliphate from the Black Sea to the Caspian Sea. I do not think that Austria and Europe would have been happy about it, or anything good would have ever come of it. But the Chechen people made an entirely different decision during voting, and eventually signed an agreement with the Russian Federation following a discussion after all the bloodshed. The Russian Federation, too, had to take a very difficult decision to give Chechnya and many other regions a status that determines the high level of their autonomy within the Russian Federation. Ultimately, that was the decision of the Chechen people, and we are very happy about this and we stick to those agreements.
"Incidentally, the same could be done in Ukraine in regard to Donbass. Why has this not been done yet? Then Ukraine would not have to limit the use of the languages of foreign minorities, meaning not only Russian, but also Romanian, Hungarian and Polish. They do not seem to discuss this much in Europe, but it is a modern reality."
Ukrainian Crisis – Putin: 'For Russia, The Important Thing Is That There Would Be No Military Facilities In Ukraine That Could Threaten Our Security, Such As New Missile Defense Systems Aimed At Thwarting Our Nuclear Potential'
Armin Wolf: "The last question on Ukraine. Do you think the Ukrainian problem would be resolved if Ukraine declared itself a neutral country like Sweden or Austria and would not join NATO?"
Vladimir Putin: "This is one of the problems, but not the only one. I have already mentioned the limited use of native languages of ethnic minorities. Ukraine adopted the law on language, which was criticized, including in Europe, but it is in force. This largely complicates the situation in Ukraine. But I will remind you – and these are the things very few people know about – that the ideologists of Ukrainian independence, Ukrainian nationalists insisted on creating a sovereign Ukrainian state, independent from Russia, as early as in the 19th century. But many of them also spoke about the need to maintain good relations with Russia, the need to form an independent Ukrainian state on federative principles, and so on. As early as in the 19th century. Today, I would say it is one of the most sensitive internal issues in Ukraine. And Ukraine is doing it itself.
"As for the neutral status, this issue is up to the Ukrainian people and the Ukrainian leadership. For us, for Russia, the important thing is that there would be no military facilities in Ukraine that could threaten our security, such as new missile defense systems aimed at thwarting our nuclear potential. This is indeed important for us, I am telling you frankly. But ultimately, this is the choice of the Ukrainian people and the country's legitimately elected authorities."
Syria – Putin: 'We Found People There Who Admitted To Having Participated In Staging The Chemical Attack [In Douma]'
Armin Wolf: "I would like to ask you a question about Syria before we move on to Russia. You say everyone is talking about the use of chemical weapons there, but the story was invented, since al-Assad and his army have no chemical weapons. Now there is proof that, although some of the attacks were indeed carried out by terrorists, al-Assad's forces accounted for others, many of them in fact. Nevertheless, Russia is blocking the decision to extend the commission's work. Why are you doing this? Why are you defending a regime that uses chemical weapons against its people?"
Vladimir Putin: "You just said there is proof accepted by everyone that al-Assad used chemical weapons. Well, not by everyone. Our experts tell it differently. For example, the case that was the reason for missile strikes against Syria after the alleged chemical attack in the city of Douma.
"Look. The Syrian troops liberated that area. We immediately suggested to our partners that the OPCW commission go there, it is a UN unit, the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons. They headed for Syria, and reached a neighboring country, Lebanon I think. But, instead of waiting one or two days and allowing the commission to work on the site, a missile attack was made on Syria.
"Tell me, please: is this the best way to ensure the objectivity of what happened there? I do not think so. I think it was an attempt to create conditions that would make it impossible to investigate thoroughly. That is what it was.
"After that, we found people there who admitted to having participated in staging the chemical attack. If you did not see it, it would be very useful for objectivity, so that your viewers could have their own opinion on this matter.
"We found children and their parents who were drenched in water and who said they did not understand what was happening. We brought them to The Hague to show everyone. Nobody wanted to listen to them. And after that you tell me: 'Everyone recognizes the use of chemical weapons.' Not everyone. We believe it is fake news, used as a pretext for the missile attack, which is a violation of international law. That was aggression against a sovereign state. Who mandated an attack on a sovereign state? The UN Security Council? No. So, what was that? Aggression."
Armin Wolf: "Mr. President, we should not talk about Douma, because the investigation is still underway there, but the international commission proved that before that, the Syrian regime had used chemical weapons often enough. And after that you wrapped this commission up in the UN."
Vladimir Putin: "Because its work is being hindered. Missile attacks were carried out days before it was to start working in Douma. What was that for? This is the first point.
"Second. The case should be investigated objectively, and we will recognize it.
"You just said there is proof that militants used chemical substances and chemical weapons. Who punished them? Tell me."
Armin Wolf: "That same commission …"
Vladimir Putin: "No, I am asking you, who punished them? Have they received any punishment? Did the coalition attack them immediately? I did not see anything like this."
Russian Economy – Putin: 'The Inflation Rate Was 12.5 percent, Almost 13 Percent, And Now It Is The Lowest In Modern Russian History – 2,5%'
Armin Wolf: "Mr. President, I am being told that we are running out of time. I would like to talk about Russia since there is very little time left."
Vladimir Putin: "Sure."
Armin Wolf: "During the election race in 2012, you promised that you will significantly improve the quality of life in Russia by 2020. However, in the subsequent years, economic growth has remained rather weak, under two percent. Wages have gone down in the past two years and the number of people below the poverty line has increased compared to 2012. Are you really just looking for foreign policy challenges to justify domestic problems?"
Vladimir Putin: "I want everybody who thinks like that to calm down. Since 2012, Russia has been through some very difficult challenges in the economy. And that was not only related to so-called sanctions or restrictions. It was primarily due to a drastic drop in the prices of our traditional export products. The prices dropped by half. That affected the budget revenue and, therefore, people's income. But we managed to do the main thing – and our colleagues, including IMF senior officials, acknowledged that just recently at the St Petersburg International Economic Forum. We achieved the main thing, which is to preserve and strengthen the macroeconomic stability in the country.
"Indeed, wages have sagged a bit along with people's incomes but if you look back to the beginning of our journey, the number of people below the poverty line is now half the number in 2000. Half that number. Between 2012 and 2016 and in 2017 the figure ticked upward but it is levelling out now.
"The inflation rate was 12.5 percent, almost 13 percent, and now it is the lowest in modern Russian history – 2,5%. Our gold and foreign currency reserves are growing. After the collapse I mentioned, stable economic growth began to show. Yes, it is modest at the moment (1.5 percent) but fixed investment is growing at 4.4 percent, which guarantees further economic growth. Foreign direct investment has almost doubled. As I said, both the Central Bank gold and foreign currency reserves and the Government reserves are growing. We have created great conditions for the next steps on economic development, which we will definitely take."
Democracy In Russia – Putin: 'Russia Is A Democracy And We All Live Under The Constitution'
Armin Wolf: "You have been President or Prime Minister for 18 years. Some people say that you have turned a country that was on its way to democracy into an authoritarian system, that you are a 'tsar' here. Is it true?"
Vladimir Putin: "No, it is not true. It is false and completely detached from reality because Russia is a democracy and we all live under the Constitution. And our Constitution says (just like the Austrian Constitution, I think) that the President can serve no more than two consecutive terms. That is why after two legitimate terms I left office, I did not try to change the Constitution and went on to serve in another role, as Prime Minister of the Russian Federation. After that, as you know, I came back in 2012, ran for president and won the election. One presidential term in Russia is six years – also like in Austria, I think.
"The voter turnout in the recent election was almost 70 percent. This is almost half of all Russian citizens. International observers had no serious criticism as to how the election was organized or regarding the election results. Therefore, there is no doubt that democracy has taken hold in Russia. It is in our interests that the country follows a democratic path of development and it will.
"The same goes for other elections, municipal and regional. Hundreds of elections take place across the country and unfailingly bring success to the political forces that win people's trust."
Alexey Navalny – Putin: 'We Do Not Want Any Second, Third Or Fourth Edition Of Saakashvili On Our Political Scene… We Do Not Need Clowns'
Armin Wolf: "However, the most prominent opposition leader in Russia, blogger Alexei Navalny, could not run for president this time. You still have never said his name in public, Alexei Navalny, even once. Why?"
Vladimir Putin: "We have many rebels here, just like in your country and the United States.
"In my conversation with your colleague I already mentioned that there was a movement in the U.S. called Occupy Wall Street. Where are they now? Gone.
"Are there not also plenty of people in Europe and Austria who promote extreme views and try to manipulate the difficulties and problems in society? Specifically, problems related to corruption.
"In Ukraine, for example, which we discussed, one of the opposition's slogans when it came to power was fighting corruption. And what is happening there now corruption-wise? What does Europe say about corruption in Ukraine? Everybody is criticizing the Ukrainian leadership for not doing enough in that area. Why do you think that we… One moment…"
Armin Wolf: "Why will you not say his name publicly?"
Vladimir Putin: "You are not letting me finish, you are being so impatient. We do not want to deal with another Saakashvili, the former Georgian president. We do not want any second, third or fourth edition of Saakashvili on our political scene. Do you like this kind of personas, a poor excuse for a politician?
"Here in Russia, we need people with a positive agenda who understand our problems deeply rather than just recite them, and we have plenty of problems just like Austria or any other country. It is easy to pick a problem and start spinning it and position yourself as the one with the solution. But without a positive starting point and ideas about how to solve problems or deal with an issue, people will not respond.
"Believe me, Russian voters are plenty sophisticated. They do not just pay attention to attractive slogans. They want to see the solutions you are proposing. And if no solution is proposed the candidate will not get noticed. What is the question about? If a person…"
Armin Wolf: "But voters did not even have a chance to get a look at this candidate because he could not run."
Vladimir Putin: "Voters can get a look at anyone because the internet is free. Nobody blocked him. Our mass media is free. People are free to speak out and make a name for themselves as representatives of many political movements do. If a person gains stature in the eyes of voters, he or she becomes a figure for the country's leaders to engage in a dialogue with. But if a political organization has the trust of one, two, three percent of people or just hundredths of a percent, then what is there to talk about? Then we get a Saakashvili. And we do not need clowns."
Armin Wolf: "I see."
"In the 2013 election in Moscow, Navalny got 27 percent."
Vladimir Putin: "How many do you think voted for yours truly in Moscow in the recent election? Not for Moscow Mayor but for President? How many do you think? Look into it."
Armin Wolf: "I would guess more than 27 percent. It is just that Navalny could not really run."
Vladimir Putin: "Yes, way more, for which I am very grateful to Muscovites. Because Moscow voters are very sophisticated. And we are not talking about a mayoral election. We are talking about a presidential election."
Putin's Political Future – Putin: 'My Presidential Term Has Just Begun. I Am Only At The Beginning Of This Journey So Let's Not Jump Ahead'
Armin Wolf: "By the end of this presidential term you will be over 70 years old."
Vladimir Putin: "I hope. (Laughter.)"
Armin Wolf: "And you will have been in power for over 20 years. As such, you will not be able to run again according to the Constitution. After this presidential term, will you leave politics or stay in power as Prime Minister?"
Vladimir Putin: "Which would you prefer?"
Armin Wolf: "It does not matter at all. I am interested in what you prefer."
Vladimir Putin: "My presidential term has just begun. I am only at the beginning of this journey so let's not jump ahead. I have never violated the Constitution of my country and I am not going to. A lot depends on the kind of job we do (and by 'we' I mean myself and my team) and what results we can achieve. But you are right, I have been in public administration, government service, for quite a long time and I need to make a decision on what I am going to do when the current term ends."
Armin Wolf: "People are speculating that a referendum will be held to make you, like Xi Jinping in China, president for life. Is it possible in Russia?"
Vladimir Putin: "I do not comment on speculation. I think it is beneath the President of the Russian Federation."
Armin Wolf: "Then, my last question, perhaps a little unusual. There are many photos of you half-naked, which is rather unusual for a head of state. These photos were not taken by paparazzi or tourists. They were published by the Kremlin. What is the story behind these photos?"
Vladimir Putin: "You said 'half-naked' not 'naked,' thank God. When I am on vacation I see no need to hide behind the bushes, and there is nothing wrong with that."
Armin Wolf: "Mr. President, you are known to be fluent in German. You have already said a few words. Perhaps, as we finish this conversation and in light of your upcoming visit to Austria, you could say something to our audience in German?"
Vladimir Putin: "Thank you for your attention.
"(In German.) Vielen Dank für Ihre Aufmerksamkeit. [Thank you for your attention.]"
